The government has no right to destroy brands that abide by the law – for once, my sympathy lies entirely with the tobacco companies – Dean
In this opinion piece in today’s SMH, creative director and social media commentator Rowan Dean asks, Why does it take so many advertisers so long to realise the best advertising is the truth?
Dean (left), a regular on THe Gruen Transfer, and a reformed smoker, argues: “By all means, make smoking illegal. You’ll get no complaints from me. But if the government is not prepared to go down that path, then it has no right to wantonly destroy brands that abide by the law. And the companies and shareholders of those brands have every right to fight for their survival. For once, my sympathy lies entirely with the tobacco companies.”
12 Comments
Hooray. Common sense! As someone who’d like to earn a living from this caper for at least another decade, I couldn’t agree with you more.
Putting the product aside, this sets a horrendously dangerous precedent for other ‘contentious’ products. If cigs are that bad, ban them. Until then, stop fucking with our industry.
His arguments have been mutilated by the SMH commenters. And not one of them have asked “But Rowan, where’s the idea in this?”
the third comment on the smh article pretty much sums it up.
gunning for a gig at a fags agency are we?
I hate smoking. But I wholeheartedly agree with you Mr Dean. This is a free economy and it’s (currently) a legal product. It sets a pretty scary precedent. Next we’ll be drinking ‘cleanskin’ beers in plainly branded cans/bottles.
Can’t fault his argument.
I think you’ll find the Govt does have the legislative right to do this, just like it was able to ban cig advertising on TV. The cost to Public Health is proven and enormous. There are limits, even in adland.
Look for new clients.
Lynchy,
Your fucking stupid Type the code thing that doesn’t recognise its own fucking numbers just made me lose a long, erudite comment that took ages.
The Government should censor these stupid fucking codes.
Yeah!
Censorship!
It fucking rocks.
Given Rowan’s contribution to smoking related misery with his Hamlet Cigars work, his position is entirely unexpected.
Ciggies rock! Onya Mr Dean
I don’t care for “brands” as much as I do for human lives. It’s that simple. And I would never ever write a cigarette ad. Not if my job depended on it. Not if you paid me $100k per brief.
Anyone who would willingly do so is completely fucked in the head.
Hmmm, he’s taking a stand but his shirt says he stands corrected?
G2 list on their website that GSK, the world’s leader in respiratory medicines, is a global client… interesting mix of business for them isn’t it?!?